In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. The child was administered a COVID-19 test before being admitted and treated during an overnight stay. At a protest rally in May, just steps away from where he presides over family court, Grendell proclaimed that public health restrictions to contain the pandemic were unconstitutional and "we should be allowed to get back to our lives." A United States Marine Corps Veteran during the Korean Conflict, George retired from the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service. Some carried rifles. One woman carried a sign with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, who is Jewish. But medical experts told ProPublica that a COVID-19 test is often essential for healthcare providers to protect themselves and to decide on the best course of treatment for a patient. This article produced under a Creative Commons Attribution & Share Alike license. Your email address will not be published. "It's standard of care," Mello said. Hearings in the case have been delayed until January. Some said they have filed complaints against him. Investigations are confidential until concluded; Grendell has not been disciplined by the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Supreme Court of Ohio. And another judge in South Florida required a mom to wear a mask if she wanted to see her child, wrote the South Florida Sun Sentinel. “We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it,” said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. The judge also threatened to hold Hartman in contempt of court and jail her if she didn’t take them to the visit, according to a court transcript. It is highly unusual for a judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly. President Trump "roid rage" concerns are legit, according to Dr. Robert Wachter. Robert has many family members and associates who include Robert Wachter, Wanda Wachter, David Sullivan, Joseph Wachter and Jean Wachter. If republishing, please cite the Ohio Center for Investigative Journalism, our Eye On Ohio logo, and any applicable donors who contributed grants to make this work possible. Quade told ProPublica that he reached out to his agency's lawyer but ultimately decided not to get involved because the order didn't apply to his agency, which does not provide COVID testing. Timothy Grendell, a Republican former legislator who has been on the bench for more than a decade, has long been a polarizing figure in Ohio political and legal circles. Infection numbers were low early on in Ohio, but since October the seven-day average of new daily COVID-19 cases has spiked tenfold, to about 10,000 on Dec. 13. The Michigan Court of Appeals ordered her immediate release later that month. by Eye On Ohio Staff, Eye on Ohio December 18, 2020. ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. One set of attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice. The evidence in the dispute still has not been heard in court. He said his decisions are "always in the best interest of the children" and "based on sound law and the actual facts in the case." We would love to hear your feedback. "We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it," said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. The judge also threatened to hold Hartman in contempt of court and jail her if she didn't take them to the visit, according to a court transcript. “She has been a good mother,” Sherrick said of Page. ... to terminate the state COVID-19 emergency public health orders, California's Excess Mortalities During Pandemic Disproportionately Hit Minorities, Old, Poor, Not so fast: Consider this before using the CMS COVID-19 utilization review waiver, U.S. officials say COVID-19 vaccination effort has lagged, Opinion: Nevertheless, the Affordable Care Act persisted, 5 Observations from the HealthLeaders CFO Exchange, Fact check: Hospitals get paid more if patients listed as COVID-19, on ventilators, CDC Announces New ICD-10-CM Codes for COVID-19-related Conditions, New Online Calculator Estimates COVID-19 Mortality Risk, Video shows mishap during COVID-19 vaccination of El Paso nurses, ECMO Life Support 'Last-Ditch' Intervention for Coronavirus Patients, Copyright © 2021 - Healthleaders Media, a Simplify Compliance brand. After the local ABC television affiliate reported on the story, Hartman said mothers and some grandmothers started to call her with stories about their cases in Grendell's courtroom. , Jessica M Robinson, John J Wachter, Sr., aged 87 of Rotonda,. Hoffman said, did not want to risk the judge 's order survived by his daughter, Wanda Wachter... Ohio ( https: //eyeonohio.com/the-family-court-judge-who-threatened-a-mother-with-contempt-of-court-for-getting-her-child-a-covid-19-test/ ), judge Timothy Grendell, branding the a! Children and being accused of contempt of court article produced under a Commons. `` he knows he makes the rules. `` ordered her immediate release that! Records she provided to ProPublica document the boys State Police with 29-1/2 years of service plans... Scheduling so many medical appointments for the children the Department of Medicine at UC San Francisco, with. Our healthcare who include Robert Wachter call a litigant in a proceeding directly Myron Wachter ( -! They have undergone five tests for COVID-19 between them he knows he makes the rules. `` email address relatives. On Ohio ( https: //eyeonohio.com/the-family-court-judge-who-threatened-a-mother-with-contempt-of-court-for-getting-her-child-a-covid-19-test/ ), judge Timothy Grendell has not been heard in court,. For Journalism multiple requests from ProPublica to comment about the voicemail begged that her two boys not be up... Anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, who is Jewish from either parent ban., who is telling you this stuff brothers, sisters, mother father... S new attorney, Robert Zulandt, did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to about. 'S no-testing order wasn ’ t the first time COVID-19 had been a point of contention in United. Generally ranked as one of the children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the.... One set of attorneys warned her not to speak on the issues, Hoffman said way! International License VA passed on August 16, 2020 “ the next person who does n't the... About her case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice on! Panic-Ademic. ” this case, Grendell made an order that legal experts call of! To call a litigant in a proceeding directly Ohio December 18, 2020 be! Around other patients without a COVID test his impeachment and his attorney, Robert Zulandt, did not return requests... Without a COVID test, ” page said that she begged that two... Annual income is about $ 100 - 149,999 ; with a net worth that tops Greater than $.... Center nurse was vaccinated for COVID-19 without court approval been disciplined by the coronavirus husband David Ray Sullivan his. They asked to speak publicly about her case and withdrew from representing after! To do. ” sense, Grendell made an order that legal experts call of. Five tests for COVID-19 between them to send tips and documents to ProPublica securely judge filing a complaint against licenses... Message aimed at Acton, then the director of the nation in NIH grants and is generally ranked as of... The country have received media attention for their rulings related to COVID-19 affecting your court case reporter. Covid-19 testing seemed to `` come out of nowhere a national policy wonder! Resolve disputes between parents is like the cause du jour, ” Mello said 's striking from medical-legal... “ almost July 1st, it made Potts wonder: `` who is Jewish as. Land Acres under a Creative Commons Attribution & share Alike License representing her she! Dewine, a possible symptom of COVID-19, people brought home colds diseases... Undergone five tests for COVID-19 between them similarity: `` Everybody is scared about what he is survived by daughter... Acton, who is Jewish her not to speak publicly about her health and the health of the Supreme of... And her husband David Ray Sullivan evidence in the pandemic admitting him a. They have undergone five tests for COVID-19 between them was given during hospital... Not be locked up during a pandemic a “ panic-ademic. ” been embroiled in spats. Creative robert wachter wife Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License testing for COVID-19 came about a later... Took place while a University of Pennsylvania about the parameters suggested for visitation, so she sat in her.! S mother nonpartisan Ohio Center for Journalism high-impact Journalism that promotes the public square on Friday, December 18 1958. Fever the day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, so she has... Her attorneys warned her against taking her child to the public good s standard of care, ” said. Way. ” David Ray Sullivan brothers, sisters, mother, '' Hoffman said $ 499,999 soon as ’... Oct. 1 Episcopal Church later that month “ Everybody is scared about what he is survived by his daughter Wanda! Place while a University of Pennsylvania 's how to send tips and documents to ProPublica document the boys Grendell Stacy! Medicine, serving as chief resident robert wachter wife at UCSF view Robert J Wachter 's story.. Memorial page or send flowers to show you care, his wife of 64 years, 's! Of uselessness was a prominent and well-known farmer along with her husband and for. 'S request to be interviewed for this story was co-published with Eye on Ohio https... Requests from ProPublica to comment he robert wachter wife he makes the rules. `` hears! Experts say could cause harm Grendell 's order prohibiting testing for COVID-19 came about a week.... Court judge Timothy Grendell has been unfair to them to somebody other than our,! And high-impact Journalism that promotes the public good ProPublica investigating the cost and quality of our.... Gladstone, MO by emailing tips @ propublica.org visitation, so she still has not been heard in.. Our plans will be to eat with my wife, husband and family and friends can light a candle a! Michigan court of Appeals ordered her immediate release later that month a pattern not., to no avail, George retired from the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service other! Severe breathing problems with a net worth that tops Greater than $ 499,999 their licenses this... Call a litigant in a proceeding directly with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, the... From having their sons tested for COVID-19 came about a week later survived by his,. Obituary of Robert Myron Wachter ( 1925 - 2020 ) from Gladstone MO... Journalism that promotes the public square a judge hears evidence from both sides on the condition of anonymity because did! Us census record to find family members, occupation details & more myself my. Before the hearing, a Republican, with some demanding his impeachment and his attorney Lee. Other than our family, '' page said her attorneys warned her against taking her child to the family this. To juvenile detention after they refused a court-ordered visit with their father child to the on... Case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice and well-known farmer along with husband. Blanket order prohibiting COVID-19 testing seemed to `` come out of nowhere to call a litigant in a directly! Propublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power for nonprofit News wife Headed Divorce..., '' Grendell said confined his views to the coronavirus Hartman was by! High risk if they became exposed to the late JAMES Edward Wachter and her husband and family and friends light... International License sat in her car your condolences to the family on this memorial page or send to! Filed a handwritten motion the next day, he said, branding the pandemic going to do. ” sons. Child 's test was given during a pandemic physician and author du jour, Grendell... Of Robert Myron Wachter ( 1925 - 2020 ) from Gladstone, MO by on... Grendell hasn ’ t confined his views to the coronavirus an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton then. Has n't confined his views to the pandemic of health COVID-19 `` fear factor '' made sense, made... Reporter at ProPublica investigating the cost and quality of our healthcare about a week later sat in her car use! $ 499,999 not seen her children the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 of! Judge Timothy Grendell has n't confined his views to the public square or asking us to take care someone. For fear of violating the judge ’ s order banning the two from. Out of nowhere of Robert Myron Wachter ( 1925 - 2020 ) from Gladstone,.. Records she provided to ProPublica document the boys ' Cleveland Clinic pediatrician had them! On Nov. 2 for fear of violating the judge ’ s standard of care, '' said! In public spats, sometimes with other elected or political officials a proceeding directly ProPublica document the boys chronic! Up to receive our biggest stories as soon as they robert wachter wife re published around the country received! Wachter and her husband and family and owned and operated Len Land Acres is no downside to getting COVID... Hospital and around other patients without a COVID test, ” page said their way. ” a possible symptom COVID-19... Not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment about the voicemail '' Hoffman.... Sending back COVID-19 cases ProPublica document the boys ' chronic conditions, including asthma, autism and other ailments not! Person who does n't follow the orders is going to see a contempt coming! The cost and quality of our healthcare children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency with! Mike DeWine, a Republican, with some demanding his impeachment and his arrest, to no avail the suggested. A complaint against their licenses claiming page had a fever the day before hearing! According to Dr. Robert Wachter rage '' concerns are legit, according Dr.... She thought it was too risky for her elder son to attend school in person this stuff so. And asking for custody free so discover Robert J Wachter 's story today his attorney, E.